Member-only story

Tender Buttons: Gertrude Stein's Unconventional Masterpiece

Doug Price

·8.2k Followers· Follow

Published in Tender Buttons Gertrude Stein

5 min read

453 View Claps

32 Respond

Save

Listen

A Photograph Of The Cover Of Gertrude Stein's Book Tender Buttons Gertrude Stein

Gertrude Stein, an avant-garde American writer and poet known for her experimental and innovative literary style, left an indelible mark on the literary landscape with her groundbreaking collection of prose poems, "Tender Buttons." First published in 1914, "Tender Buttons" defied literary conventions, challenging readers with its enigmatic language and unconventional structure.

This article explores the profound impact of "Tender Buttons," examining its unique characteristics, critics' responses, and Stein's own perspective on her enigmatic masterpiece. Through an analysis of representative poems and critical interpretations, we delve into the intricate web of themes and motifs that have fascinated and puzzled readers for over a century.

Tender Buttons

by Gertrude Stein

4.1 out of 5

Language	:	English
File size	:	1031 KB
Text-to-Speech	:	Enabled
Screen Reader	:	Supported
Enhanced typesetting	:	Enabled
Word Wise	:	Enabled
Print length	:	59 pages

An Unconventional Poetic Landscape

"Tender Buttons" consists of three sections, each characterized by a distinct approach to language and form. In the first section, "Objects," Stein reduces everyday objects to their elemental qualities, creating a series of haiku-like poems that evoke the essence of things without explicitly naming them.

A carafe, that is not a carafe, that is a blind glass. A kind in glass and a cousin, a spectacle and nothing strange A single hurt color and an arrangement in a system to pointing. All this and not ordinary, not unordered in not symmetry.

In the second section, "Food," Stein turns her attention to the sensory experience of food, juxtaposing evocative descriptions with abstract language to create a surreal and dreamlike atmosphere.

Asparagus as a green color and white taste, and not ordinary not unordered in not symmetry.

The third section, "Rooms," explores the domestic space through a series of fragmented vignettes that blur the boundaries between interior and exterior, reality and imagination.

In the grass in the white grass there is a cow, in the white grass there is a red cow. In the white grass there is a red cow with a white horn.

Critical Reception and Controversy

"Tender Buttons" was met with a mix of bewilderment and acclaim. Critics were divided, some praising Stein's innovative style and others dismissing it as incomprehensible nonsense.

Early reviews were highly polarized. Some critics, such as Marianne Moore, praised Stein's "uncompromising vision" and her "ability to perceive the subtlest relationships." Others, such as H.L. Mencken, found her work "meaningless" and "fraudulent."

Over time, "Tender Buttons" gained increasing recognition as a seminal work of modernism. Critics such as Harold Bloom and Marjorie Perloff have hailed Stein's linguistic experimentation and her subversion of traditional poetic forms.

Stein's Perspective on Her Work

Stein herself remained unapologetic about the enigmatic nature of her writing. She believed that her work transcended conventional forms of logic and reason, seeking to evoke an intuitive and immediate experience in the reader.

In her essay "Composition as Explanation," Stein wrote: "I do not like to repeat myself, but if a thing remains real and if I repeat it again, it does not matter. There is a difference between repetition and the thing repeated." She argued that language was not merely a tool for communication but a dynamic, self-referential system that could reveal new insights.

Themes and Motifs

"Tender Buttons" explores a wide range of themes and motifs, including:

Identity and the Nature of Self: Stein's poems often question traditional notions of identity and subjectivity, suggesting that the self is a fluid and multifaceted entity.
Perception and Reality: "Tender Buttons" challenges the idea of a fixed, objective reality, inviting readers to question their own perceptions and experiences.
The Power of Language: Stein's experimental use of language in "Tender Buttons" demonstrates the transformative potential of words and the limitations of conventional expression.
The Domestic and the Everyday: Through her exploration of domestic objects and spaces, Stein invites readers to reconsider the significance of the everyday and the ordinary.
Modernity and Urban Life: "Tender Buttons" captures the fragmented nature of modern urban experience, with its rapid pace and sensory overload.

Gertrude Stein's "Tender Buttons" stands as a testament to the power of literary experimentation, challenging conventional norms and inviting readers to engage in a profoundly different way with language and reality.

Whether one embraces Stein's radical vision or remains perplexed by its obscurity, "Tender Buttons" has undoubtedly left an enduring mark on the literary landscape, inspiring generations of writers and artists with its unconventional approach and unwavering commitment to innovation.

Tender Buttons

by Gertrude Stein

4.1 out of 5